A Practical Guide to Notices, Proceedings, Reply Drafts & Case Law Under the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001
INCOME TAX NOTICES & THEIR REPLIES
Penalties | Offences | Prosecution
This book will walk you through what FBR notices mean and how to deal with them calmly and confidently. The book explains the legal purpose of each notice, the relevant statutory provisions, practical compliance requirements, available legal remedies, appeal procedures, offences, penalties and prosecution provisions in a simple and practical manner.
The book contains detailed commentaries on the income tax notices, offences, prosecutions and penalties for non-compliances with the provisions of the income Tax Ordinance 2001, supported with the Income Tax Rules 2001, the FBR’s Circulars, SROs, and Case Laws.
CONTENTS:
CHAPTER – 1 : PRELIMINARY
✔ Definitions
✔ Ordinance to override other laws.
CHAPTER – 2 : INCOME TAX NOTICES, MEANINGS & HOW TO RESPOND?
✔ Income tax notices are issued for compliance:
✔ Understanding different types of income tax notices;
✔ The FBR contacts and why it matters;
CHAPTER – 3 : COMMON TYPES OF INCOME TAX NOTICES & RESPONSES THEREOF
✔ Common types of income tax notices
✔ Notice issued to furnishing a return of income
✔ Notice issued for deemed assessment scheme
✔ Notice for furnishing a wealth statement
✔ Notice for foreign assets/income statement
✔ Notice for assessments
✔ Notice show-cause notice for rectification of mistakes
✔ Notice for additional information
✔ Notice for recovery from person holding money on behalf of taxpayer
✔ Notice under sections of withholding taxes regime
✔ Notice for monitoring of withholding taxes
✔ The Commissioner shall issue orders
✔ Notice to obtain information or evidence
✔ Notice under section 176(1), 214(c) and sec. 177)
✔ Notice to call for records/documents within 6 years
✔ Income tax notices regarding audit and amendment
✔ Show-cause notices for penalties, refunds, and other matters.
✔ 239B. Reference to authorities
CHAPTER – 4 : INCOME NOTICES FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE ORDINANCE
✔ You need to know
✔ The taxpayers’ obligations etc. Specified by the FBR
✔ The FBR’s obligations towards taxpayers
✔ Receipt of income tax notice and your response thereon
✔ Detailed steps to check income tax notices
CHAPTER – 5 : ESSENTIAL STEPS TO FOLLOW UPON RECEIVING AN INCOME TAX NOTICE
✔ The expression ‘Income tax notice’ defined
✔ Essential steps to be followed upon receipt of a notice
✔ Essential steps for handling of a notice
✔ Key aspects regarding income tax notice
Format – Income tax notice reply letter
✔ Furnishing - documents, service of documents, forms and notice
✔ R. 73. Furnishing of documents and returns etc.-
✔ Format of an authority letter to e-intermediary
✔ R.74. Service of documents electronically.-
✔ R.75. Forms and notices.-
CHAPTER – 6 : APPEALS AGAINST THE INCOME TAX NOTICES ISSUED BY THE COMMSISSIONER etc.
✔ Legal appeal forums
✔ Common grounds for challenges
✔ The procedure of filing an appeal
✔ R.76. Appeal to the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) on web portal. –
✔ R. 76A. Date of filing of appeal. –
✔ R.76B. Documents to accompany appeal. –
✔ R. 76C. Intimation of filing of appeal to the respondent.–
✔ R.76D. Filing of affidavit regarding contrary facts.-
✔ R.76E. Defective appeals etc.-
✔ R.76F. Power of attorney etc., by authorized representative
CHAPTER – 7 : NON-FILERS AND NON-COMPLIANTS MUST KNOW
✔ Every non-filer and non-compliant must know
✔ Why is this notice issued?
✔ Real-world scenario:
✔ Judicial precedents
✔ Expert insights
✔ A notice triggers
✔ Key take-away
✔ Pro tips to stay compliant
✔ Step-by-step: Responding to section 114(4) notice:
✔ Penalties for non-compliance (section 182)
✔ Your compliance of notice is not optional, it’s a legal imperative;
CHAPTER – 8 : THE COMISSIONER ISSUES INCOME TAX NOTICES TO THE TAX PAYERS
✔ Types of income tax notices and the reasons for their issuance
✔ The Commissioner may, by notice in writing, require a person or a person’s representative for compliance:
✔ The taxpayer’s response/compliance
✔ R.75 - Forms and notices
✔ The Commissioner issues notices:
✔ 4B. Super tax for rehabilitation of temporarily displaced
✔ FCC declared the section 4C intra vires of the constitution
✔ The section 4B shall apply to the income arising to E&P companies:
✔ 4C. Tax on high earning persons
✔ Exemption to banking companies:
✔ The FCC declared the super tax u/s 4C intra vires of the constitution:
✔ The order of the Islamabad High Court is set aside:
✔ The section 4C shall apply to the income arising to E&P companies
✔ The section 4C shall not apply to
✔ Computation, collection and payment of tax u/s 4C by NCCPL:
✔ Recovery of super tax only after adjustment of pending refund claims, FTO:
✔ 74. Tax year
✔ Review application to the board against commissioner's refusal order:
✔ 101A. Gain on disposal of an asset of a non-resident company:
✔ 108. Transactions between associates
✔ 108A. Report from independent chartered accountant or cost and management accountant.
✔ 109. Re-characterization of income and deductions
✔ 110. Salary paid by private companies
✔ 111. Unexplained income or assets
✔ The foreign remittance exception
✔ Format – a notice issued by the DC to the taxpayers 111(1)
✔ How to check and respond the notice received
✔ 114. Return of income
✔ The Commissioner’s powers to issue notice u/s 114(3)
✔ Notice where the commissioner is of the opinion to submit return:
✔ Format – Notice to be issued by department of IR u/s 114(4)
✔ 114B. Powers to enforce filing of return
✔ 116. Notice is issued to furnish wealth statement
✔ R.36. Furnishing wealth statement
✔ 116A. foreign income and assets statement
✔ R.36A. Foreign income and assets statement
✔ Penalty for failure to furnish the statement
✔ 117. Notice of discontinued business
✔ The Commissioner may issue notice where business is discontinued:
CHAPTER – 9 : INCOME TAX NOTICES ISSUED FOR ASSESSMENTS & REASSESSMENTS
✔ 120. Assessment
✔ 121. Best judgment assessment
✔ Show cause for best judgment assessment
✔ 122. Amendment of assessment
✔ Format - Notice issued by the commissioner IR u/s 122
✔ Key operational provisions include
✔ Limitation to authority to modify the assessment
✔ 122A. Revision by the commissioner
✔ 122B. Revision by the chief commissioner
✔ 122D. Agreed assessment in certain cases
✔ 122E. Faceless audit and assessment
✔ 123. Provisional assessment in certain cases
✔ 124. Assessment giving effect to an order
✔ 124A. Power of tax authorities to modify orders etc.
✔ Supreme Court of Pakistan set aside SHC verdict
✔ 125. Assessment in relation to disputed property
✔ 126. Evidence of assessment
✔ The FBR’s directives for selection of cases through CRM based system
CHAPTER – 10 : APPEALS AGAINST THE ORDERS PASSED BY THE COMMISSIONER
✔ 127. Appeal to the commissioner (Appeals)
✔ 128. Procedure in appeal
✔ Comply with the procedure for filing an appeal;
✔ R.76. Appeal to the commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) on web portal. –
✔ R.76A. Date of filing of appeal. –
✔ R.76B. Documents to accompany appeal. –
✔ R.76C. Intimation of filing of appeal to the respondent.–
✔ R.76D. Filing of affidavit regarding contrary facts.-
✔ R.76E. Defective appeals etc.-
✔ R.76G. Procedure for filing and disposal of stay application.-
✔ R.76I. Hearing of appeal or stay application.-
✔ R.76L. Reports. –
✔ R.76M. Uploading manual orders/letters received:
✔ R.76N. Electronic order:
✔ R.76O. Explanation.
✔ R. 78. Prescribed form for reference to High Court.
✔ 129. Decision in appeal
✔ Your actions on receipt of the order:
✔ R.76J. Notice to be issued electronically to both parties under sub-section (2) of section 129.
✔ 129A. Faceless appeals
✔ 130. Appellate Tribunal IR
✔ 131. Appeal to the Appellate Tribunal
✔ 132. Decision of appeals by the Appellate Tribunal
✔ 133. Reference to High Court
✔ Your Action
✔ 133A. Independent case security committee
CHAPTER – 11 : ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION COMMITTEE
✔ 134A. Alternate Dispute Resolution
✔ R.231C. Alternative Dispute Resolution
✔ 136. Burden of proof
CHAPTER – 12 : INCOME TAX NOTICES FOR COLLECTION AND RECOVERY OF TAX DUE
✔ 137. Due date for payment of tax
✔ Format - Notice issued by the Commissioner IR u/s 137(2)
✔ 138. Recovery of tax out of property and through arrest of taxpayer.
✔ Format - Notice to be issued by the Commissioner IR u/s 138(1)
✔ Reply of the above notice
✔ R.122. Definitions.-
✔ R.123. Form of notice of recovery to be issued by Commissioner.-
✔ R.124. Mode of service of notice.-
✔ R.125. Time limit for execution of the notice.-
✔ R.126. Disposal of proceeds of execution.-
✔ R.127. Determination of disputes.-
✔ R.128. Exemption from attachment.-
✔ 138A. Recovery of tax by district officer (Revenue).
✔ 138B. Estate in bankruptcy
✔ 139. Collection of tax in the case of private companies & AOP and association of persons
✔ 140. Recovery of tax from persons holding money on behalf of a taxpayer
✔ Format – Notice to be issued by the Commissioner IR u/s 140
✔ Demand recovered by attachment of bank account, was held Illegal by the ATIR
✔ FTO directed to FBR to unfreeze account
✔ R. 69. Section 140 notice.-
✔ R. 210A. Definitions.-
✔ R. 210B. Notice of recovery to be issued by Commissioner
✔ R. 210C. Service and compliance of notice.-
✔ R. 210D. Determination of disputes.-
✔ R. 210E. Appeal.-
✔ R. 210F. Receipt to be given.-
✔ R. 210G. Withdrawal of notice.-
✔ R. 210I. Board may issue instructions. –
✔ 141. Liquidators
✔ 142. Recovery of tax due by non-resident member of AOP
✔ 143.Non-resident ship owner or charterer
✔ 144. Non-resident aircraft owner or charterer.
✔ 145. Assessment of persons about to leave Pakistan.
✔ Format - Commissioner’s notice issued u/s 145
✔ 146. Recovery of tax from persons assessed in Azad Jammu and Kashmir or Gilgit-Baltistan.
✔ 146A. Limitation, validity, etc. of recovery proceedings.
✔ 146B. Tax arrears settlement incentives scheme.—
✔ 146C. Assistance in the recovery and collection of taxes
✔ 146D. Recovery of liability outstanding under other laws
CHAPTER – 13 : THE COMMISSIONER MANAGES COLLECTION OF INCOME TAX THROUGH NOTICES
✔ The concept of deduction/collection of tax at source
✔ Responsibilities of withholding tax agents
✔ FBRs’ system for management of withholding data’s
✔ Core duties and responsibilities of withholding agents
✔ Core concepts
✔ Key requirements
✔ Key steps
CHAPTER – 14 : PROVISIONS OF COLLECTION / DEDUCTION OF TAXES AT SOURCE
✔ Presumption tax regime (PTR)
✔ Time and manner of deposit of tax etc.
DIVISION – I : ADVANCE TAX AND DEDUCTION / COLLECTION OF TAXES AT SOURCE
✔ Scheme of payment of advance income tax
✔ The Commissioner may issue notice
✔ 147. Advance tax paid by the taxpayer
✔ 147A. Advance tax from provincial sales tax registered person
DIVISION – II : ADVANCE TAX PAID TO A COLLECTION AGENT
✔ 148. Imports
✔ Penalties revised
✔ R.40A. Application.-
DIVISION – III : DEDUCTION OF TAX AT SOURCE
✔ R.40D. Import under an exemption certificate.–
✔ R.40E. Import under a reduced rate certificate.–
✔ 149. Salary
✔ 150. Dividends
✔ 151B. Certain payments by life insurance companies and takaful operators.
✔ Tax on certain payments by life insurance business
✔ Withholding mechanism
✔ The Commissioner notice and your response
✔ 152. Payments to non-residents
✔ Income tax shall be deducted from amount payable to a non-resident person (NRP) on account of the following services:
✔ R. 18. Income from royalty .-
✔ R.19. Fee for technical services
✔ The Commissioner’s notice and your response
✔ 153. Payments for goods, services and contracts
✔ Penal provisions
✔ 155. Rent of immoveable property
✔ 16. Non-adjustable amounts received relation to buildings
✔ 15. Income from property
✔ 15A. Computation of income chargeable under the head ‘income from property’
✔ 156. Prizes and winnings
✔ 156A. Petroleum products
✔ 158. Time of deduction of tax
DIVISION – IV : THE MAJOR ADVANCE TAX COLLECTION/DEDUCTION UNDER VARIOUS SECTIONS
✔ 5AA. Tax on return on investment in Sukuk
✔ 6. Tax on certain payments to non-residents
✔ 6A. Tax on payments for digital transactions in e-commerce platforms
✔ 7. Tax on shipping income and air transport income of a non-resident person
✔ 7A. Tax on shipping of a resident person
✔ 7B. Tax on profit on debt
✔ 7C. Tax on builders
✔ 7G. Tax on certain payments by life insurance business
DIVISION – V : TRANSITIONAL ADVANCE TAX PROVISIONS
✔ 231B. Advance tax on private motor vehicles
✔ 231C. Advance tax on foreign domestic workers.
✔ 233. Brokerage and commission
✔ 234. Tax on motor vehicle
✔ 235. Electricity consumption
✔ 236. Telephone and internet users.
✔ 236A. Advance tax at the time of sale by auction
✔ 236C. Advance tax on sale or transfer of immovable property
✔ 236CA. Advance tax on TV plays and advertisements
✔ 236CB. Advance tax on functions and gatherings.
✔ 236G. Advance tax on sales to distributors, dealers and wholesalers.
✔ 236H. Advance tax on sales to retailers.
✔ 236O. Advance tax under this chapter
✔ 236Z. Bonus shares issued by companies.
✔ R.231G. Determination of value of bonus shares issued by a company not quoted on the stock exchange, to the shareholders of the company.
CHAPTER – 15 : BANKING COMPANIES SHALL COLLECT/DEDUCT TAX AS WITHHOLGING AGENTS
✔ 151. Profit on debt
✔ 151A. Gain arising on disposal of certain debt securities.
✔ 151B. Certain payments by life insurance companies and Takaful operators.
✔ Rate of tax on premium paid to the policy holders
✔ 154. Export
✔ 154A. Export of Services
✔ 154B. Withholding tax on revenues received from social media platforms.
✔ 231AB. Advance tax on cash withdrawal
✔ 236y. Advance tax on persons remitting abroad through credit /debit prepare cards.
CHAPTER – 16 : THE COMMIIONER MONITORS COLLECTION OF TAXES THROUGH THE BNKING COMPANIES & FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
✔ 164A. Settlement of transactions liable to Withholding Tax by SWAPS agents
✔ 165. Statements
✔ R.44. Statement of tax collected or deducted.-
✔ R.45. Statement of tax deducted under the Sixth Schedule to the Ordinance.-
✔ 165A. Furnishing of information by banks
✔ R.39A. This chapter shall apply to the banking companies reporting requirement for the purposes of section 165A of the ordinance.
✔ R.39B. The information:
✔ R.39C. Authorized Persons.-
✔ R.39D. Time of furnishing information.-
✔ 165AB. Reporting of financial transaction data by banking companies and financial Institutions.
✔ 165B. Furnishing of information by financial institutions including banks
✔ R.78A. Application. –
✔ R. 78B. Definitions.- n this Chapter, −
✔ 165C. Furnishing of information by online marketplace, payment intermediary and Courier service.
✔ R.38A. Statement to be furnished by online marketplace
✔ How to prepare RECONCILIATION STATEMENT
CHAPTER – 17 : GENERAL PROVISIONS RELATING TO THE ADVANCE PAYMENT OF TAX OR THE DEDUCTION OF TAX AT SOURCE
✔ 160. Payment of tax collected or deducted
✔ R.43. Payment of tax collected or deducted
✔ 161. Failure to pay tax collected or deducted
✔ 162. Recovery of tax from the person from whom tax was not collected or deducted
✔ 163. Recovery of amounts payable under this Division
✔ R.123. Form of notice of recovery to be issued by Commissioner.-
✔ R.124. Mode of service of notice.-
✔ R.125. Time limit for execution of the notice.-
✔ R.126. Disposal of proceeds of execution.-
✔ R.127. Determination of disputes.-
✔ 164. Certificate of collection or deduction of tax
✔ R.42. Certificate of Collection or deduction of tax
✔ R.43. Payment of tax collected or deducted.-
✔ 166. Priority of tax collected or deducted
✔ 167. Indemnity
✔ 168. Credit for tax collected or deducted
✔ 169. Tax collected or deducted as a final tax
CHAPTER – 18 : REFUNDS
✔ 170. Refunds
✔ R. 71. Section 170 application.-
✔ R.72. Section 175 authorization.-
✔ R.210IA. Application. –
✔ R.210IB. Establishment of centralized income tax refund office (CITRO).–
✔ R.210IC. Sanction and payment of refund.–
✔ 170A. Electronic processing and electronic issuance of refunds by the board
✔ 171. Additional payment for delayed refunds
✔ 171A. Payment of refund through income tax refund bonds.
✔ The FTO has urged the FBR to launch a faceless IT refund system
CHAPTER – 19 : REPRESENTATIVES, RECORDS, EVIDENCE
✔ 172. Representatives
✔ 173. Liability and obligations of representatives
✔ 174. Records
✔ 176. Notice to obtain information or evidence
✔ The Taxpayers’ response:
✔ Judicial interpretation of this section may be relied in dealing with the notice is received from the Commissioner
CHAPTER – 20 : TAX AUDIT
✔ 177. Audit
✔ The Commissioner shall process tax audit:
✔ Statute of limitation
✔ The ATIR has directed the Commissioner to pay cost to the authorized representative:
CHAPTER – 21 : PENALTIES, OFFENCES & PROSECUTIONS
✔ Key points: : Late filing of income tax returns
✔ 182. Offences and penalties
✔ Your response to the notice received from the Commissioner (Supreme Court Ruling)
✔ The Schedule of penalties u/s 182 of the ordinance
✔ Applying penalties u/s 182, 184 and 186 of the income tax ordinance 2001 under repealed ordinance are legally unsustainable and unlawful declared by the by the SC:
✔ 182A. Return not filed within due date
✔ 183. Exemption from penalty and default surcharge
CHAPTER – 22 : ISSUANCE OF INCOME TAX NOTICES OFFENCES AND PROSECUTIONS
✔ Key Offences leading to prosecution:
✔ 191. Prosecution for non-compliance with certain statutory obligation.
✔ 191A. Prosecution for failure to furnish information in return of income
✔ 191B. Prosecution for non-registration
✔ 192. Prosecution for false statement in verification.
✔ 192A. Prosecution for concealment of income.
✔ 192B. prosecution for concealment of an offshore asset.
✔ 193. Prosecution for failure to maintain records.
✔ 194. Prosecution for improper use of NTN Certificate.
✔ 195. Prosecution for making false or misleading statements.
✔ 195A. Prosecution for non-compliance with notice u/s 116A
✔ 195B. Prosecution for enabling offshore tax evasion.
✔ 196. Prosecution for obstructing an income tax authority.
✔ 197. Prosecution for disposal of property to prevent attachment.
✔ 198. Prosecution for unauthorized disclosure of information.
✔ 199. Prosecution for abetment.
✔ 200. Offence by companies and AOP.
✔ 201. Institution of prosecution proceedings without prejudice to other action.
✔ 202. Power to compound offences.
CHAPTER – 23 : TRIALS OF OFFECES BY THE SPECIAL JUDGES
✔ 203. Trial by special judge.
✔ 203A. Appeal against the order of special judge.
✔ 203B. Power to arrest and prosecute.
✔ 203C. Procedure to be followed on arrest of a person.
✔ 203D. Special judges.
✔ 203E. Cognizance of offences by special judges.
✔ 203F. Special judge etc. to have exclusive jurisdiction.
✔ 203G. Provisions of code of criminal procedure, 1898 to apply.
✔ 203H. Transfer of cases.
✔ 203I. Place of sittings
✔ 204. Power to tender immunity from prosecution.
CHAPTER – 24 : CIRCULRS & ADVANCE RULING
✔ 206. Circulars
✔ 206A. Advance ruling
✔ R 231A. Procedure for issuance of advance ruling
✔ 231B. Withdrawal of application.-
CHAPTER – 25 : DEFAULT SURCHARGE
✔ 205. Default surcharge.
✔ 205A. Reduction in default surcharge, consequent to reduction in tax or penalty.
CHAPTER – 26 : ADMINISTRATION
PART – I : GENERAL
✔ Journey from CBR to FBR:
✔ 207. Income tax authorities
✔ 208. Appointment of income tax authorities
✔ 209. Jurisdiction of income tax authorities
✔ 209B. Faceless jurisdiction of income tax authorities
✔ 210. Delegation
✔ 211. Power or functions exercised
✔ 212. Authority of approval
✔ 213. Guidance to income tax authority.
✔ 214. Income tax authorities to follow orders of the board
✔ 214A. Condonation of time limit
✔ 214B. Power of the board to call for records.
✔ 214C. Selection for audit by the board.
✔ 214E. Closure of audit.
✔ 215. Furnishing of returns, documents etc.
✔ 217. Forms and notices, authentication of documents.
✔ 218. Service of notices and other documents.
✔ 219. Tax or refund to be computed to the nearest rupee.
✔ 220. Receipts for amounts paid.
✔ 221. Rectification of mistakes.
✔ 222. Appointment of expert.
✔ 222A. Fee and service charges.
✔ 223. Appearance by authorized representative.
✔ 224. Proceedings under the ordinance to be judicial proceedings.
✔ 225. Proceedings against companies under liquidation.
✔ 226. Computation of limitation period.
✔ 227. Bar on suits in civil courts.
✔ 227A. Reward to officers and officials of Inland Revenue
✔ 227B. Reward of whistleblowers.
✔ 221BA. Reward and benefits for certain persons.
✔ 227D. National faceless center
✔ 227E. E-hearing.
PART – II : DIRECTORATE – GENERAL
✔ 228. D.G. Internal audit
✔ 228A. D.G. (Field compliance) I.R.
✔ 229. Inland revenue service academy
✔ 230. D.G. Intelligence and investigation IR
PART – III : DIRECTORATE – GENERAL
✔ 230A. D.G. of withholding taxes
✔ 230B. D.G. of law
✔ 230C. D.G. research and development
✔ 230D. D.G. of broadening of tax base
✔ 230E. D.G. international tax operation
✔ 230F. D.G. of immovable property
✔ 230G. D.G. of special initiative
✔ 230H. D.G of valuation
✔ 230I. D.G. of compliance risk management
✔ 230J. International centre of tax excellence.
✔ 230k. Tax fraud investigation wing inland revenue
✔ Jurisdiction order corporate RT karachi
✔ Jurisdiction changes of the tax officers.
CHAPTER – 27 : MICELLNEOUS
✔ 237. Power to make rules
✔ 237A. Electronic record
✔ 237B. Prize schemes to promote tax culture
✔ FBR designated IR field formation
✔ Withholding Agents under each relevant section – Annex – A